all shall be well all shall be well and all manner of things shall be well julian of norwich

Saturday, December 27, 2008

1) it felt that the white and handsome Scott was viewed as the proper lover and the Hispanic Jack was viewed as needy, hotheaded. it seemed to be literally whitewashed.
2) there was not alot about fucking. mainstream movies about queer lives still have no idea how to handle the fucking.
3) it made his less noble connections invisible, but this might be a matter of history already done--i would like to see a solid investigative piece about how he interacted with/used the People's Temple to consolidate votes, for example.
4) it was a step back formally, for Van Sant, who's last few movies were these elliptical, almost anti plot, diversions about sex, desire, history, lust, and death----the aesthetics of paranoid park, elephant or last days could have been used really effectively for Milk, and it seems to be this horribly didactic step backwards.
5) and this is my most complicated point. I think that we have treated Dan White badly, as a community, and I think that this movie does as well. A bunch of things---Milk treated White badly, he manipulated him, promised things and didn't deliver, pulled the rug underneath him, stonewalled his issues, and they were legitimate issues, whether we agree with White or not--Milk refused to treat him democratically, no matter how much he used the mantle of electoral politics to maintain progress. The sticking point between Milk and White seems to be more about land use, then anything else. White was mentally ill, under finical pressure, unable to feed or take care of his wife and kids, and viewed his masculinity being threatened. When he was convicted of manslaughter, it was the system working--he was suffering from diminished capacity, and continued to be. There is something almost bathetic about this man returning home, unable to live with the enormity of his crime, and doing what so many gay men and lesbians wished during the white night riots.
5) I think it does a disservice to Milk's collation building that White is treated so simply, or at least Milk's attempts at coalition building before he became (as the film says) the gay boss tweed.
6) All of that said, I am unsure of how prescriptive it is, is Milk's moving from a general radical stance to a more assimilationist one, from a broad coalition to a v. specific identity politics something that the glbtq community (as if there is one community) should attempt to assimilate?


(and a movie about Dan White would be much more interesting I think)

2 comments:

Diane said...

This is one of your finest reviews/posts. You make a lot of salient points and your views/ideas make a great deal of sense. Thank you.

Anonymous said...

and the new visual scheme is a real evolution

Blog Archive

About Me

i am a sixteen foot sasquatch.